The insole drawer

Written by the founder

Almost everyone who buys an insole from us has bought two or three before. They are in a drawer. This is about why those did not work, and what we did differently.

There is a specific kind of disappointment that comes with the third pair of insoles.

The first pair you buy with hope. Your feet hurt by two in the afternoon, someone says try insoles, you spend fourteen dollars on Amazon and for about a week it is better. Then it is not. The second pair you buy with a plan. You read the reviews this time, you pick the one with the arch, you pay twenty-two. Same week of relief. Same slow return to the way it was.

By the third pair you are not really buying insoles. You are buying one more chance to be wrong about your own feet.

What is actually in the cheap ones

Cut one open. Almost all of them are the same thing: a sheet of moulded polyurethane foam, sometimes with a plastic arch shell glued under it, sometimes with a fabric top.

Foam does one job well and one job badly. It compresses beautifully the first time. Under load it displaces, spreads the pressure, and the relief is immediate and real. That is why the first week works.

The bad job is coming back. Every compression cycle breaks a few cell walls. A person on their feet for an eight-hour shift puts somewhere around eight thousand steps through each insole per day. After a few weeks the foam has taken a permanent set: it is now a thin flat sheet in the shape of your foot, and it has stopped giving anything back.

The insole did not stop working. It finished working. Foam has a fixed number of good compressions in it, and a cheap one has fewer.

This is not a scandal and nobody is lying to you about it. It is just what foam is. The problem is that it is sold as a solution and it behaves like a consumable.

What we put in instead

The cushion in our insole is not a sheet. It is moulded as hundreds of separate closed cells, each one a few millimetres across, standing on their own.

A finger pressing into the green cell structure of the Easegait insole, each cell compressing separately.
Press one cell and its neighbours do not move. That separation is the whole mechanism.

When you step, the cells under the loaded part compress and the ones beside them do not. Each cell is a small independent spring made of latex rather than polyurethane, and latex has a much higher resilience: it returns closer to its original height, more times, before it takes a set.

You can feel the difference with your thumb before you ever put them in a shoe. Press a flat foam pad and it dents and slowly relaxes. Press a cell and it comes back up under your finger.

There is a second thing the cell structure gives you for free. Because the cells stand apart, there are channels between them, and the moulding runs perforations through the whole length. Air moves. A sealed foam pad in a work shoe becomes a hot, damp surface by hour six, and that is its own kind of misery.

The part nobody in this category will talk about

Sizing.

Go and read the one-star reviews on any insole on Amazon. A large share of them are not about comfort at all. They say it bunched at the toe. It rode up at the heel. It was fine in the sneaker and impossible in the work boot. It made the shoe too tight.

The industry sells insoles in ranges, a men's 8 to 10, a women's 6 to 8. Your foot is one size and the shoe you are putting it in is another, and the range is a compromise between the two. When the compromise lands wrong, the insole gets returned, and the customer concludes that insoles do not work for them.

Wrong size is the most common reason an insole comes back. So we took size out of the decision.

Ours is trimmed. You take the old insole out of the shoe, lay it on top of the new one as a template, and cut the toe end with ordinary kitchen scissors. The cell structure cuts clean and holds its edge, because each cell is closed on its own and there is no sheet to tear or fray. The offcut is a crescent of material and the job takes under a minute.

Household scissors cutting the toe end of the insole, with the trimmed crescent of material beside it.
Cut once, in the shoe you already own. The edge holds because every cell is closed on its own.

We are, as far as we can find, the only brand in this category that leads with this. Everyone else sells you a size and hopes.

The length we do publish

Before trimming, here is what the moulding measures end to end. Trim down from the nearest size above yours.

EU 35–36 37–38 39–40 41–42 43–44 45–46
cm 23 24 25 26 27 28
in 9.06 9.45 9.84 10.24 10.63 11.02

What this is not

It is not a treatment. We are not going to tell you it corrects your gait, fixes plantar fasciitis, reverses a bunion or realigns anything. If you have a diagnosed condition, the person to ask is a podiatrist, and an insole bought on the internet is not a substitute for that conversation.

It is a cushion. A well-made one, in a structure that keeps working longer than the flat pad in your drawer. That is the entire claim, and we would rather make a small claim we can stand behind than a large one that falls apart in month two.

What we can prove, and what we cannot

We can show you:

  • The cell structure, in a photograph, compressing under a finger.
  • That it cuts clean, with the offcut in frame.
  • The measured length of every size.
  • Unedited reviews of this cushion, including the critical ones.

We cannot show you:

  • A clinical trial. There has not been one, and any brand in this category telling you otherwise should be asked for the citation.
  • A doctor's endorsement. We have not paid for one.
  • A number of days until your feet feel better. That depends on your feet, your shoes and your floor, and anyone quoting you a figure invented it.

Easegait launched this year. We are not going to pretend to be older than we are, and we are not going to put a stock photo of a man in a white coat on this page. What we have instead is a ninety-day trial, which is a longer window than most people need to know.

What buyers of this cushion actually say

The reviews below are for the same cushion, taken from the manufacturer's listing rather than from our own customers, because we have not been selling long enough to have a meaningful number of our own. We have not edited them.

“I work 12-hour shifts and these are hard toe shoes and it feels like I'm walking on cloud all day.”

Verified buyer

“Be careful with the size, it runs small, so take 1 or 2 sizes larger.”

Verified buyer

“Good quality. Similar quality to Target/Walmart at a fraction of the cost.”

Verified buyer

We left the middle one in deliberately. It is the sizing complaint, it is accurate, and it is the exact problem the trim answers: order the size above and cut down.

Ten hours in. Still comfortable.

One pair, cut to the shoes you already own. Ninety days to decide.

Shop the insole

Easegait sells cushioned insoles and related footcare equipment. Nothing on this page is medical advice and no product we sell is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any condition. If foot pain is persistent, severe, or accompanied by numbness or swelling, see a clinician. The ninety-day trial is a refund of the purchase price and is not a promise of any particular result. Reviews quoted above are attributed to their source in the text and were not written by us.